receipt-capture-gbp

What to look for when choosing a bookkeeper

A good bookkeeper gives you records you can trust, on a routine you can rely on, in a file you own. Before you hire anyone, it pays to understand what the role covers, how the work is priced and what a well-run month looks like. If you’re specifically looking for a bookkeeper in Penrith, our local page covers that. This guide is general advice for any Australian small business.

Below we cover who does what, the checks worth running, how pricing models compare, what to get in writing, and how to switch smoothly if your current arrangement isn’t working.

Bookkeeper, BAS agent or accountant: who does what

These roles overlap, so it helps to be clear about which one you actually need.

  • Bookkeeper: keeps your day-to-day records up to date. That usually means coding transactions, reconciling bank and card accounts, entering supplier bills and customer invoices, and producing monthly reports.
  • BAS agent: a bookkeeper who is also registered with the Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) and can prepare and lodge your business activity statements for a fee. If you want your bookkeeper to handle the BAS, this is the registration to look for.
  • Accountant or tax agent: uses your records for year-end financial statements, income tax returns and tax advice. A bookkeeper or BAS agent hands clean records over to them rather than replacing them.

Most small businesses need a bookkeeper who can also handle the BAS, plus an accountant at year end. Our article on the difference between a bookkeeper and an accountant goes into more detail.

Registration and insurance checks

If someone will prepare or lodge your BAS, look them up on the TPB public register. The register is free and public, so there’s no reason to take a registration on trust. Check that the name matches the person or business you’re dealing with and that the registration is current.

Registered BAS agents must also hold professional indemnity insurance that meets TPB requirements, so ask them to confirm it. If a provider says they don’t need to be registered, ask exactly which tasks they will and won’t do. Our guide on whether a bookkeeper can lodge your BAS explains where the line sits.

Pricing models and what to get in writing

Bookkeepers generally charge in one of two ways.

  • Fixed monthly fee: you know the cost in advance, which makes budgeting easier, and you’re not watching the clock every time you send a question. The trade-off is that the fee is set for an agreed workload, so it needs reviewing if your business grows or changes.
  • Hourly rate: can suit very small or irregular workloads, but the monthly cost is harder to predict and messy months cost more. Ask for an estimate and how time is recorded.

Whichever model you choose, ask for an engagement letter or service agreement before work starts. It should set out:

  • the tasks included, and how often each one is done
  • the tasks that are charged separately, and how those are quoted
  • when the fee will be reviewed, and what triggers a change
  • what you need to provide each month, and by when
  • the notice period, and what happens to your file if you leave

Published prices make comparison easier. Our plans and prices are Starter $399, Advanced $549 and Premium $849 per month plus GST, with no lock-in contract. For a closer look at what a monthly package should cover, see what monthly bookkeeping packages should include.

Software, data access and ownership

Your accounting file is one of your business’s most important records, so set up access carefully from day one.

  • Keep the subscription in your name. The business owner should be the subscriber and hold the top-level login. Your bookkeeper is then invited as a user.
  • Give each person their own login. Never share your own password or your online banking details. Individual logins keep a clear audit trail of who changed what.
  • Check user roles. Give your bookkeeper the access they need for the agreed work, and review it when the scope changes.
  • Know where your documents live. Receipts, bills and reports should be stored in your file or a system you control, not only in someone’s inbox.

Ask which software the bookkeeper uses every day. We work in Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks. If you’re thinking about changing systems, plan it separately from changing bookkeepers. Our software migration service covers that.

Communication, turnaround and the month-end routine

Good bookkeeping is a routine, not a once-a-quarter scramble. Before you sign, ask the bookkeeper to walk you through a typical month:

  • when transactions are coded and accounts reconciled
  • when you’ll receive your reports, and which reports they are
  • how they’ll send you questions about unclear transactions, and how long you have to answer
  • how quickly they usually reply to emails or calls
  • who covers the work when they’re on leave

A clear month-end routine means your BAS is prepared from records that are already reconciled, rather than rushed together near the due date. If BAS is part of the job, see how our BAS preparation and lodgement fits into the monthly cycle.

Comparing bookkeepers now? Ask us anything on this list. We’ll tell you what’s included, what isn’t, and which plan fits before you commit. Talk to us about your bookkeeping.

Red flags to watch for

  • They ask for your own login or your online banking password instead of their own user access.
  • There’s no engagement letter, or they’re reluctant to put the scope in writing.
  • They’re slow to reply before you’ve even signed. It rarely improves afterwards.
  • Your reports show large unreconciled balances or a growing suspense account month after month, with no explanation.
  • They can’t explain in plain English what they did for you last month.
  • They offer income tax returns or tax advice without being a registered tax agent.

Questions to ask in a first call

Beyond fees and registration, these questions show how a bookkeeper actually works:

  1. Who will do my work day to day, and who do I contact if they’re away?
  2. Can you show me an example of the monthly reports I’ll receive?
  3. How do you handle a transaction you’re not sure how to code?
  4. What access do you need to my software and bank feeds, and how do you keep it secure?
  5. How do you quote for one-off work, such as a catch-up or a clean-up?
  6. If we stop working together, how do you hand the file back?
  7. What do you expect from me to keep things on schedule?

Listen for specific, practical answers. A bookkeeper who has a clear process will be able to describe it without hesitation.

How to switch bookkeepers smoothly

Changing bookkeepers is easier than many owners expect, as long as it’s planned.

  1. Pick a clean cut-off. The end of a month or a BAS period makes it clear who is responsible for what.
  2. Confirm your access first. Make sure you hold the top-level login to your accounting file before you give notice.
  3. Request the records. Ask for the latest reconciliations, lodged BAS copies, payroll reports and any open queries.
  4. Have the new bookkeeper review the file. They should check opening balances and agree how any backlog will be handled before ongoing work starts. A catch-up or clean-up may be needed first.
  5. Remove old access. Once the handover is complete, remove the previous provider’s user access.

Our guide to changing bookkeepers lists the records and software steps in more detail.

Ready to compare?

365 Bookkeeping and BAS provides bookkeeping, payroll and BAS work for small businesses across Australia, with a registered BAS agent on the team. You can see our plans and prices, or book a free 30-minute chat and ask us every question on this list. We’ll look at your file and tell you which plan fits before you commit.